Legitimacy: Who can generate it?


Posted by Helena Cobban
October 19, 2009 7:29 PM EST | Link
Filed in Afghanistan

This is a huge question in Afghanistan. It was earlier a huge question in Iraq-- but it turned out that Nuri al-Maliki had a wily (and previusly unrecognized) understanding of this question.

Does Abu Mazen understand it? Good question...

(Note: John Locke may have been a racist, an investor in the transatlantic slave trade, and had many other moral flaws. But he was, nonetheless, the prime author in western thinking of the concept that legitimacy stems from the consent of the governed.)

These days, generating "legitimacy" in Afghanistan is a deep, deep problem. So are elections, which are (a) very hard to organize, and (b) necessarily very divisive in post-conflict contents.

Back to the more inclusive loya jirga approach, maybe? December 2001.



Comments
Comment from... Salah, at October 19, 2009 07:55 PM:

but it turned out that Nuri al-Maliki had a wily (and previusly unrecognized) understanding of this question.

I don't know Helena what you means by Maliki understanding?

He still with his mate living in Green zone they can not move from it unless secretly or with heavy security forces.

Do you mean in your question that he is doing what been told to do?

Comment from... Salah, at October 20, 2009 09:06 PM:


Ryan Crocker. Speaking at the Harvard Kennedy School on Friday he told a large crowd not to kid themselves that America's adventure in Iraq is all but over. "It's still just getting under way," he said. "Huge challenges that neither we nor they can identify, will emerge in the future."

Please add your own comments that are courteous, fresh, helpful, and to the point. Be aware that comments might take a minute or two to post because of the extensive filtering we need to use. Comments that contain a number of links may be delayed so that I or my tech advisor can give approval for their publication. Generally this should not take too long. ~HC









Remember personal info?










Recent Posts on JWN
• Nozette: Pollard, 2.0? (24)
• Legitimacy: Who can generate it? (2)
• New horizons ahead! (14)
• J Street blogger panel--next Monday! (2)
• Olmert, author of assault on Gaza, shunned in Chicago (24)
• IPS analysis of 'Galbraith-gate' (6)
• UN-HRC endorses Goldstone; Netanyahu's over-reach unraveling? (41)
• Good reporting from RFE/RL on Galbraith/DNO (8)
• 'The Nation' piece on AIPAC's Tom Dine (1)
• More on Galbraith; Boston Globe runs the story (12)
• NYT studiously ignores Galbraith-DNO link (9)
• RIP Leila Abu-Saba (3)
• Turkey's intriguing diplomacy (34)
• Exploring the Geneva Initiative (3)
• IPS piece on Abbas's waning popularity (9)
• Nonsense from Blair (25)
• Peter Galbraith, oil contracts, and Kurds (26)
• Obama's Nobel (21)
• China and the US in Afghanistan (6)
• Daniel in the lions' den (4)
• Gitmo, Kafka, and the abuse of 'law' (1)
• US-UN power tussle over Afghanistan? (6)
• Israelis reconsidering views of 'the Other' (35)
• Khomeini guardian's jarring question (4)
• Goldstone's careful documentation & argument (7)
• Abu Mazen's legitimacy plunging (15)
• Pathetic sock-puppetry in comments (59)
• Long knives in Ramallah over Goldstone? (19)
• Jackson Diehl finally loses his sanity? (5)
• Palestinian society supports Goldstone, criticizes Abbas (1)
• Goldstone's mission gets key acknowledgment (11)
• Palestinian political update (4)
• ParabĂ©ns, Brazil! (6)
• IPS piece on global power shifts and Iran (1)
• Obama wrong on the Olympics (7)
• Some good news on Iraq (13)
• Happy 60th birthday, China! (2)
• Good start on Goldstone, Michael Posner (19)
• Israel's religio-nationalists considered (12)
• Palestinian independence, borders, and Jerusalem (3)
• Palestinian reconciliation update (0)
• MP3 audio: Who Speaks for the Palestinians? (0)
• Afghanistan: Obama's Vietnam? (3)
• Iran sanctions and-- Jerusalem (42)
• My IPS piece on dimming peace prospects (3)
• Rahm Emanuel's disturbing view of US role (29)
• Obama's peacemaking pledge-- to the world (35)
• Obama: Peace in US interest (5)
• Discussing Palestine, Israel, Iraq on Bloggingheads (0)
• Long knives, Washington, Afghanistan, part 2 (7)