IPS piece on the rights war over Gaza


Posted by Helena Cobban
September 11, 2009 5:49 PM EST | Link
Filed in Gaza08-09 , Human rights , Israel-2009

... is here, also here. My last word on this important subject for now.



Comments
Comment from... Salah, at September 12, 2009 02:38 PM:


رسالة لأهل غزة من جيش الدفاع الإسرائيلي ٧,١,٢٠٠٩

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8sznMP3dnCg&feature=related

Comment from... Salah, at September 12, 2009 02:41 PM:

Forgot to put this.
The above video was created by:

idfnadesk
Joined: 29 December 2008
Last Sign In: 2 days ago
Videos Watched: 303
Subscribers: 24,253
Channel Views: 2,401,723
The IDF Spokesperson's Unit is the Israel Defense Forces' professional body responsible for media and public relations in Israel and around the world. This is our new site that will help us do so.

We thank you for visiting us and will continue to update this site with documentation of the IDF's humane action and operational success in Operation Cast Lead.

Please visit the IDF's new blog - www.idfspokesperson.com - for news and other multimedia content.

Comment from... Derick Schilling, at September 13, 2009 09:32 PM:

Copied forward from an earlier thread:

Can some one explain to me why, if the IDF was engaged in widespread and indiscriminate killing of civilians during Operation Cast Lead, do women account for only 12% of the fatalities reported by the PCHR and B'Tselem?

I am also curious as to how many of the minors under the age of 16 were over the age of 14, as opposed to 14 and younger.

Ms. Cobban writes:

"PCHR put the complete death toll among Gazans at 1,419. B'tselem put it at 1,387. That's a difference of 32 people. The difference could perhaps be explained by what they were counting: PCHR was counting the number of Palestinians 'killed during the Israeli military offensive on the Gaza Strip,' while B'tselem was apparently counting Palestinians killed by the Israeli security forces."

So does the difference represent the number of Palestinians who were summarily killed by the Hamas security forces during the fighting?

Please add your own comments that are courteous, fresh, helpful, and to the point. Be aware that comments might take a minute or two to post because of the extensive filtering we need to use. Comments that contain a number of links may be delayed so that I or my tech advisor can give approval for their publication. Generally this should not take too long. ~HC









Remember personal info?










Recent Posts on JWN
• My IPS piece on dimming peace prospects (1)
• Rahm Emanuel's disturbing view of US role (26)
• Obama's peacemaking pledge-- to the world (35)
• Obama: Peace in US interest (5)
• Discussing Palestine, Israel, Iraq on Bloggingheads (0)
• Long knives, Washington, Afghanistan, part 2 (7)
• Long knives out in Washington over Afghanistan (3)
• Amal Saad-Ghorayeb responds (10)
• NATO and Lebanon (16)
• IPS piece on Obama-Netanyahu tussle over priorities (0)
• Gaza police and noncombatant immunity (46)
• Gaza, the Obama administration, and the present (4)
• Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, "benchmarks" (2)
• Barak: Iran not existential threat (0)
• Garlasco, suspended with full pay (15)
• Me, speaking Sept 24 at Middle East Institute (3)
• Goldstone Commission reports on Gaza-war war-crimes (23)
• Another blunt No from Netanyahu (30)
• Ramadan t.v. offerings, 2009 (2)
• I-P: Borders first-- and fast? (4)
• A testimony the world needs to hear (2)
• Garlasco, part 3 (32)
• Malley on refugees, settlers, etc (7)
• In 2009, as 2001: US needs Iran, Russia (3)
• IPS piece on the rights war over Gaza (3)
• Garlasco, part 2 (20)
• Continuing bad news for US/NATO in Afghanistan (4)
• Marc Garlasco's little "hobby" (71)
• Trashing one-staters with Hussein Ibish (12)
• 500 new settlement homes in Jerusalem... (12)
• When election results are disputed: Afghanistan, etc (6)
• B'tselem's figures on Gaza assault toll (8)
• American power has limits? Who knew? (13)
• Israel's assault on Gaza: The final toll (1)
• Hamas-related negotiations moving forward? (1)
• Sweden, and the Israel-linked organs story (18)
• Qtube-- what a resource! (2)
• Cook and Elam on Israel's organ-removal problems (48)
• "The White House regrets... " (48)
• Lessons from the Soviet experience in Afghanistan (9)
• IPS analysis of Iraq and related regional tensions (1)
• Visser goes 2.0 (8)
• More on Norway's targeted divestment (14)
• Pat Lang on the dangerous, continued rise of 'COIN'-mania (8)
• Bravo, Norway! (6)
• An exiled Palestinian visits "home" (20)
• Israel releases nine of 32 Hamas legislators (2)
• Why Blair wants Dahlan to retake Gaza? (0)
• Afghanistan debate: The missing international ingredient (9)
• State-building: Palestine (3)