Violence in Mumbai, love at home


Posted by Helena Cobban
November 29, 2008 12:08 AM EST | Link
Filed in Violence/nonviolence

My condolences to all who have lost loved ones to the terrorist violence in Mumbai. Most of those killed and wounded have reportedly (and not surprisingly) been Indians. But tens of westerners, including US citizens, Brits, and Israelis have also been killed, many of them having reportedly been directly targeted. Each life lost is equally shocking. Each is a loss to the universe.

I've had the huge joy of spending much of the past two days with my one-month-old grand-daughter, Matilda. Holding her, and breathing in her baby softness, is a wonderful and restoring thing to do in a world marked by far too much violence. She is so special in every single way. And she has two extremely devoted and capable parents.

But as I appreciate this little person's special-ness, I am also acutely aware that in a sense she 'represents' every other baby, every other person in the world.

All should be equally loved and equally supported.

Unimaginable to think that a baby like her could be targeted for punishment if she happened to be in Mumbai, or in Gaza, or D.R. Congo at this time. Our world is a terrible fractured place. Fractured mainly by the woundedness of all those who wish-- and do-- violence to others.

Hatred can only ever be overcome by love.



Comments
Comment from... Bob Spencer, at November 29, 2008 07:16 AM:

Your statement is probably intellectually accurate as it is emotionally or philosophically important. For example, researchers have long known that the most effective method to prevent youth violence and criminal behavior is for young people to bond with healthy adults. Other research repeatedly shows that peer and community influences along with the perception that come hell or high water “I will make it” has more to do with preventing violence than most other factors.

We do not apply that knowledge in Washington DC where about 300 people die each year. We do not apply it in Afghanistan where almost all sources of tribal and community leadership are dead or have become refugees. We do not apply it in the isolated Pakistani ghettoes of England and Europe that have produced the 9/11 terrorists and the London bombers.

Oliver Roy, the distinguished French scholar, talks about theses underlying causes in NYT columns and in his books. He says that they cannot find attachment and fulfillment no matter how economically successful they become.

Too often, we choose to repel the people that need to be brought closer. “You are with us or against us.”

Bob Spencer

Comment from... escott, at November 29, 2008 01:03 PM:

Powerful observations....

Found myself caught at the Philadelphia Airport yesterday, talking for just a brief few minutes to my son, the Lieutenant, just as he was at the Atlanta airport awaiting "export" to Iraq. Talk about fractured hearts....

I'm still thinking of him as the irrepressible infant, fearlessly, yet adorably exploring underneath the kitchen sink and cabinets, in our UVA Copeley Hill apartment, -- a quarter century ago.

Now today, we have Jessica, Keith's one-year-old daughter, here with us for a gathering.....

Yes, the love still flows.

Please add your own comments that are courteous, fresh, helpful, and to the point. Be aware that comments might take a minute or two to post because of the extensive filtering we need to use. Comments that contain a number of links may be delayed so that I or my tech advisor can give approval for their publication. Generally this should not take too long. ~HC









Remember personal info?










Recent Posts on JWN
• Goal of the Mumbai attacks: Sparking India-Pakistan war? (0)
• Raed Jarrar discussing the SOFA/WA (0)
• Violence in Mumbai, love at home (2)
• The Iraqi SOFA/WA: Uncertainties-- but also a text (1)
• Buiter announces collapse of western financial system (34)
• What is the economy FOR? (4)
• Karzai wants the foreign troops out, too (1)
• Iraq's international 'Contact group' becoming stronger? (0)
• Rumsfeld, Kagan, and Chalabi in the NYT (18)
• U.S. in Iraq: Good-bye 'Conditionality' (12)
• US power declining. Duh. (8)
• Newsflash! Russia lets NATO trans-ship weapons to Afghanistan (1)
• Some great (but under-heard) experts on the Muslim world (7)
• L. Rozen on Israelis in Kurdistan (1)
• Mr. Obama, tear down this war! (0)
• Red Queen Perino declares 'Victory' in Iraq (7)
• Logistical impasse for the US in Afghanistan? (1)
• Specter, Tierney spearheading diplomatic engagement with Iran (1)
• Australia's thought-provoking Apology (3)
• Israel attacks Gaza, demonstrates it is still the 'occupying power' (1)
• Urgent memo to Bush: Tell us honestly what this agreement with Iraq says (26)
• Some Iranian support for the US-Iraq SOFA: Why? (1)
• Prunier on Laurent Nkunda and the DRC crisis (16)
• Operation Enduring Failure (4)
• Gaza at crisis point (4)
• Use the Detroit bailout to transform US transit (9)
• Casino capitalists in the brainwash-Iraqis biz (7)
• G-20: When 'Seven' just isn't enough (4)
• R. Emanuel apologizes for dad's racist comments (102)
• Gender and casino capitalism (5)
• Neglected Veterans Day (2)
• Let's see the audacity in Obama's Mideast policy, too! (4)
• The Syria raid and a whole White House gone rogue (2)
• Don Bacon: New occasional poster here (2)
• Look What's Hiding Behind the SOFA (4)
• More on R. Emanuel and US Mideast policy (53)
• Requirements for Obama appointees (1)
• An informed eye on today's casino capitalism (5)
• A Gandhian talisman for Barack Obama (2)
• 'China Hand' on extrajudicial killings (3)
• First big global challenges for Obama (4)
• Congratulations, Tom Perriello! (0)
• R. Emanuel: Repudiate this disgusting racist comment (23)
• An Egyptian-American at Grant Park (1)
• Thinking of My Son the Lieutenant (0)
• Obama draws out the best in others (15)
• America enters the 21st century (2)
• To get out of Iraq... (4)
• Obama's key cabinet picks... (3)
• "The Reign of Witches" ending. (2)